Dinner & Show: 5 Hidden Gem Restaurants in St Augustine
Are you celebrating a birthday, anniversary, friendship or love? Join us for a special evening at the Magic Hideaway – a luxury magic show inside the Casa Monica Resort and Spa, with world renown entertainer Bill Abbott.
Dining before or after the show completes the evening and whether you’re a local wanting to discover fresh dining gems or a visitor craving an authentic taste of St. Augustine, this guide is your key to extraordinary culinary experiences before or after your show at the Magic Hideaway.
We’ve handpicked our favorite five exceptional restaurants within the downtown historic district—all within a leisurely walk to the show—perfect for a seamless evening of dinner and entertainment.
And don’t miss the exclusive BONUS at the end: an unforgettable, lavish show experience that will make your evening truly magical.
These five restaurants offer not only exceptional cuisine, but also the charm of St. Augustine’s historic streets—each one within a short leisurely walk to your evening entertainment. Perfect for a date night that flows effortlessly from dinner to show.
Modern Steakhouse Elegance in a Historic Setting
Located within the iconic Casa Monica Resort & Spa, Cordova Coastal Chophouse offers an intimate dining experience inspired by Spanish and Moroccan influences. The atmosphere is rich with curated art, a sophisticated wine selection, and impeccable service.
Splurge on the prime filet, served with the house’s signature steak sauce—it’s a standout. Pair it with elevated sides like crispy smashed potatoes, foraged wild mushrooms, or charred broccolini. Their wine list is among the finest in town, making this a top choice for both visitors and locals in the know.
A perfect start to an indulgent evening, just steps away from the show Magic Hideaway inside the Casa Monica Resort and Spa.
Timeless Charm with Chef-Driven Fare
Tucked inside a beautifully restored 19th-century inn, Old City House is a hidden gem where historic ambiance meets gourmet cuisine. The menu features refined takes on classics, with locally sourced seafood and seasonal ingredients. Dine in the romantic courtyard or elegant dining room—both perfect for an unhurried, intimate evening.
French-Inspired Fine Dining in a Boutique Setting
La Nouvelle offers an elevated French dining experience in a warm, modern space with an open kitchen concept. Expect impeccable plating, artfully balanced flavors, and attentive service. Dishes change seasonally, but the duck confit and house-made pâté are local favorites. A must for those who appreciate culinary craftsmanship with European flair.
Cozy Wine Bar with Parisian Soul
This charming wine bar on Charlotte Street brings effortless European style to St. Augustine. The Drunken Horse serves curated charcuterie boards, French cheeses, and boutique wines by the glass in a cozy, candlelit setting. It’s intimate, relaxed, and ideal for conversation over a bottle before strolling to your show.
Romantic Dining with an Eclectic Twist
Regularly ranked among the best restaurants in St. Augustine, Collage offers globally inspired cuisine with a fine-dining edge. With its soft lighting, richly appointed interiors, and standout dishes like lobster ravioli and beef tenderloin, it’s a destination for romance and celebration. The extensive wine list and impeccable service seal the deal.
Are you foodies who love lesser-known dining spots with unique culinary experiences? We saved the best for last!
An Enchanting show experience to an Unforgettable Evening
Before or after indulging in dinner at one of St. Augustine’s hidden culinary gems, elevate your evening with a truly captivating performance at The Magic Hideaway—a luxurious, speakeasy-style experience unlike anything else in the city.
Tucked within the historic Casa Monica Resort & Spa, this intimate theater sets the stage for an evening of wonder, illusion, and elegance. World-renowned magician Bill Abbott brings mind-bending magic and masterful sleight of hand to center stage, with a personal touch that makes every guest feel like part of the show. The experience is both grand and personal.
When: Saturday evenings, at 6:00 p.m. and 8:30pm (during busy season)
Where: Casa Monica Resort & Spa, 95 Cordova Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Parking: Valet parking is available for $25. Guests dining at Cordova Coastal Chophouse enjoy a reduced valet rate of $5.
What’s Included:
* A complimentary welcome cocktail
* Table-side magic
* Pre-show sleight-of-hand entertainment
* The main performance in an intimate, stunning showroom
* A post-show meet-and-greet with Bill Abbott for photos and autographs
Dress Code: While formal attire isn’t required, most guests embrace the occasion with cocktail or business casual wear.
Audience: Appropriate for guests of all ages, minors must be accompanied by an adult.
Booking Information
Due to the exclusive nature of the experience and limited seating in the intimate venue, advance reservations are highly recommended.
Secure your spot for an unforgettable night of wonder:
👉 Book Tickets to the Show
